There's not been a lot of work on managers and how they affect the game, but Jaffe's work goes a long way in that regard.
He also says "the details are incredible" of the managers he read. Always nice to hear that.
There's not been a lot of work on managers and how they affect the game, but Jaffe's work goes a long way in that regard.
It’s good stuff. . . . It’s a very detailed view about what makes managers successful (or unsuccessful for that matter). If you like baseball history, order this book.
Jaffe's Evaluating Baseball Managers is well-researched and well-written.
In his book “Evaluating Baseball’s Managers” (MacFarland) Chris Jaffe writes the ultimate book on the effect of baseball managers on their team’s success and failure
After reading the excerpt on the Mets managers, I look forward to picking up a copy of Evaluating Baseball Mangers
I would consider this book an essential reference for the amateur (or professional) baseball historian.
Jaffe’s coverage of managers is an ideal blend of statistics and history. You don’t need to be a numbers cruncher to understand or to enjoy the relevance of the statistics Jaffe provides in the book. He provides a thorough depiction of each manager—not only giving a description of their character, but the reputations that they gained throughout the course of their career. And he does a fantastic job at providing statistical evidence to back his claims.
[T]his book will appease the history folks, the stat heads, and anyone looking for arguments on the history of baseball.
[I]t is simply a must-read for any self respecting baseball nerd.
Thanks to Chris Jaffe, you might never look at the men in the dugout the same way.
Good sportswriting should increase understanding or stimulate thought. Evaluating Baseball's Managers hits it out of the park on each count.
What Jaffe does with all these guys is highlight why they were good or why they weren't successful. He does an excellent job of it, providing stats to back it up in each manager's capsule, but also backing it up with solid analysis. Bullpen usage, hitting for power, walks, and more are shown as trends for each manager as Jaffe does a good job of describing what kind of team each guy oversaw. It's exactly what history buffs would want and provides the kind of source material that analysts will be using for years.
The big test for me these days on anything related to the Dodgers is whether I learn something and whether I'm entertained in the process, and Jaffe succeeds in both.
I would strongly encourage everyone to purchase a copy. I’ve pre-ordered mine and from what I’ve read among the excerpts, I can’t wait to read the whole thing.
The work going on at THT is some of the most interesting (and lucid) modern baseball analysis you'll see, and Jaffe's book appears to be a solid extension of that work. It's already on my Christmas list
I was highly impressed with the quality of analysis conducted by Jaffe. His writing is clear, and to the point. Although the book is based on stats, I never felt the writing was dense. Jaffe does not just plop statistics onto the reader. Instead he uses the stats to tell a story about each manager he profiles.